Friday, December 5, 2008

amy: Popes of Avignon

I began to see how little I truly understood about the complexity within the Catholic Church when Garrett Severson first informed me about there being more than one pope. When Garrett Lambur’s group spoke on the divide between the French and Roman pope, I found out how much there is to know on that subject. It enlightened me as to the function of the church at that time period. The church was the political power. This explains a lot. Not to say that I never understood the Catholic Church was involved in politics, I just never realized how much. Back in those days, and even somewhat today, Catholicism had the power to control entire societies. When Rome and Avignon began disputing over which pope is the “right one,” they hit a major crisis within the religion as a whole. This is interesting to me because the Catholic papacy was as interested in maintaining power over Europe as Napoleon or any emperor within western history. I also find it very sad. As much as Catholicism tries to create a cohesive set of rules for the average person, this point in history goes against everything Christ preached. When Peter tries to start a revolution in the Garden of Gethsemane, Jesus rejects his physical revolution and goes with the soldiers peacefully. Christianity is never supposed to be a physical revolution, but an inward, spiritual revolution through Christ. It becomes evident the leaders of the time became so focused upon maintaining power that they were not able to focus on the real problems happening within the church. Most of the reformers did not want a rift within the European church, but the papacy was unable to make the proper adjustments in the church because of their distraction of politics.

amy: Protestant and Catholic Relations

Recently, my interest in Catholicism has grown. I have been raised within a family that would be labeled perhaps as “Protestant,” but it was more than simply going to church on Sunday. Both my parents stressed the importance of living faith. Faith was not an idea that one merely occasioned on Sundays to “become pure.” It is a lifestyle that is lived out every day. There was never any separation between the sanctity in a church building versus our own home. In fact, the denomination in which I was raised never called church “church.” It was always called meeting due to the idea that the church is made up of the believers and not the building.
Needless to say, the ideas of Catholicism have always bewildered me. I never understood why certain practices would be taken so seriously if it was not explicated in the Bible. Events kept happening in my life that made me more and more curious as to the nature of Catholicism. A friend converted to Catholicism from a Protestant church and that fueled the fire; my brother spoke to me about how Catholic monks spend their lives dedicated to interpreting the Scripture. Now, as we study the Protestant Reformation and the Medieval era, I begin to get a collective picture of the Catholic church. I think I become very torn with the idea of Catholicism. Some of the traditions within Catholicism are beautifully orchestrated, almost art within themselves, yet without the reality of true faith and devotion to Christ are hollow and meaningless. I have also struggled with the mandate of the religion. These traditions are traditions. To me, this means that they should not be required for the person to be a true believer in Christ. I think I am still working out how to think of Catholicism as a labeled “Protestant.”

Infant Jesus Museum

Yesterday we went to the Infant Jesus Museum located in the church of the same name. I honestly went to laugh at the display, and found it incredulous that it even exists. To enter the museum, we walked up a circular stairway surrounded by pictures of the wax baby Jesus clothed in many different ornate outfits. Once we finally reached the museum, we got to see the actual extravagant outfits in glass display cases, along with the actual jewel-studded crown the wax figurine wears, and the three lace slips that go underneath the dresses. Oh yes. It was good.

As we descended the stairwell, surrounded by the baby Jesus fashion show, Caroline commented that although people make fun of such elaborate uses of money, it was similar to the woman pouring the expensive perfume on Jesus’ feet. Some of the disciples complained because the money could have been better used, to feed the poor, but Jesus replied, “Why do you bother the woman? For she has done a good deed to Me. For you always have the poor with you; but you do not always have Me. For when she poured this perfume on My body, she did it to prepare Me for burial. Truly I saw to you, wherever this gospel is preached in the whole world, what this woman has done will also be spoken of in memory of her.”

After Caroline mentioned this, I responded that the two circumstances were quite different, and after looking at Jesus’ exact response I feel that with more certainty. It does raise a point, however, since in general I have been struggling with the church’s obvious use of money for elaborate buildings and artwork… Although I still believe that the church should be using far more of its resources to help the poor and relieve oppression, since that is at the heart of Jesus’ message, being reminded of the woman pouring expensive perfume on Jesus’ feet and his response to the disciple’s critique of her actions has made me reevaluate my critique of the church. Maybe there are times when God can be glorified by the money being used for a different reason than helping the poor.

eks

Thursday, December 4, 2008

Christian Perfection

In class today we discussed the life of John Wesley and consequently his doctrine on Christian Perfection. In learning about the background on the debate, we discussed Palagius and Augustus and Calvin, but I was most surprised to learn about a Quaker theologian who believed in immediate sanctification. He believed that when a person became a believer, he was no longer capable of sinning. I honestly had no idea that people believed this, and was shocked.

How can a person really believe that they no longer sin? Are they living in a delusion? What happens when they have a selfish or bitter thought? Do they believe thoughts don’t count? Doesn’t Jesus say that to be angry with your brother is the same as committing murder against him?

And where does that leave mercy, grace, and forgiveness? Repentance? Isn’t part of the wonder that God can continually forgive us? Doesn’t Jesus teach us to pray, “Forgive us our debts?”

If I understood correctly, those who hold to an immediate sanctification believe that once saved, we gain the spirit of God within us and with that spirit sin is impossible. I can see some substance to this. God is incapable of sinning, so I can understand how it would seem we are incapable of sinning once he comes inside of us. Assuming we do sin, however, I have to wonder once he is inside of us does he always stay inside of us? Can he come and go? I remember being taught as a child that our sinful flesh can “dethrone” Christ in our lives, so it would make sense that although he is always with us, we can take him off the throne of our lives as assume control, and that would be when we sin.

As I thought of this more, a dilemma arose. I guess I always assumed that our act of sinning dethroned Christ in our lives. That would seem to mean, however, that we sinned at the same point that he was in control of our lives, and therefore we acted in sin simultaneously with him being on our throne, and only during the act did our flesh take over. That doesn’t seem possible. But what is the alternative? God knows when we are about to sin, so he takes himself off the throne of our lives just beforehand?

I still am completely convinced that as Christians we continually struggle with sin, but I am now forced to question how that is possible if the spirit of Christ is living inside of us, which cannot sin.

And beyond that issue is the question of even the possibility of perfection. Is Christian perfection in this life even attainable? It doesn’t feel possible, but scripture does command us to be holy as our heavenly Father is holy. I guess I always assumed that our sanctification was an ongoing process, whose completion would only come when we are taken to heaven. Maybe that is the case, but why was the command given? Why not “try to be holy as close to possible as your heavenly Father is holy”?

This issue of perfection on earth is completely new to me; I will really want to search the scripture more to find an answer. For now, however, it’s enough that the question has been raised. My lack of knowledge challenges me to search deeper, not give up.

eks

Faith and Deeds

In chapel this morning, Dr. Redick spoke about faith and read passages from Genesis and Galatians regarding Abraham’s near-sacrifice of Isaac. He then mentioned the James passage that “faith without deeds is dead” and in contemplating that verse with the example of Abraham, a brand new thought occurred to me.

The role of deeds in our faith and salvation is a common topic of discussion. Are we saved by faith alone? Are works necessary for salvation? If not, what is their role? I have often pondered this without coming to a firm conclusion. The Bible seems pretty clear that we did nothing to merit our salvation, and yet it also seems clear that we must have good deeds. I do believe that we can do nothing to save ourselves, so in that sense it is by belief in the grace of God alone that we are saved. How could our few meager works even be enough to gain us salvation? However, I do not believe a person could be “saved” if they do not exhibit any “good fruit.” If they have no good works at all, how can they be saved? And what does “faith without deeds is dead” mean?

In thinking of this verse in light of the story of Abraham, I reached a new conclusion. Faith without deeds is dead because if you have no deeds, it shows you have no true faith. You need deeds to test and show your faith. It is not as if someone could truly have faith and not exhibit deeds… there is no faith without deeds, hence without good works, faith is dead. (And “deeds” doesn’t mean just doing good works, but obeying the Lord’s direction. If Abraham had chosen to not sacrifice Isaac, a decision no one could have blamed him for, it would have shown that he didn’t truly have faith in the goodness and promise of God.)

Faith without deeds is dead, because there is no faith without deeds. How could you really believe in God, without obeying his commands, or at least making a consistent effort to? How could you claim to believe in his promises, if you don’t act upon that belief? There can be no faith without deeds, which is why works are so important. Although you are not saved by your works, they are a sign to yourself and to God that you have really placed your faith in Him.

eks

Amanda- Christian Reformers

Although it took many years and the ideas of many men to reach the culmination of the reformation, Martin Luther is often credited and associated the most with this movement. To be honest, I had barely heard of Wycliffe and Hus prior to this semester (forgive me Kip) and yet Luther was greatly influenced by the works of these men. I found our discussion on the impact of the printing press on the success of Martin Luther to be very interesting but I feel that this idea again attributes too much importance on Luther.

Of course, the printing press is a large reason why Luther is more well known that Wycliffe and Hus, but I do not believe that the printing press was the sole reason the reformation came to a head during Luther’s time. I do not think that people would have been ready for the mass spreading of Luther’s ideas along with translations of the bible had it not been for Hus and Wycliffe paving the way before him. These two men in particular committed their whole lives to their faith, and were absolute revolutionaries.

In particular, the example of Hus being a martyr for this cause was vitally important for the people of Europe to understand his commitment to the truth, and the importance of the message of these reformers. The gradual process that occurred between the lives of Wycliffe, Hus and Luther spanned over a hundred years and that amount of time was incredibly necessary for the reformation to occur. The reformation was not just a spreading of ideas, it called for a complete change in society and way of life and it took time for people to understand that. This great move away from the Catholic Church could not happen over night, yet once the people were ready for reform there was no turning back.

The Idea of Perfection

Jenna Wynn

Yesterday the class came to a discussion about the idea of someone who can achieve “perfect love” or be a “perfect Christian.” I'm not sure if that is exactly where the discussion lead towards, but I wanted to touch upon this idea of people who claim themselves to have achieved perfection. Whether it be just all around perfect, or perfect in their Christianity or their spirituality.
I'm going to state this very blatantly but I believe people who claim to be perfect in their love and in their religion are completely arrogant. Yes, I believe people can become very spiritual and have extremely good habits, but just the very idea that they believe they are perfect is a sin and very flawed.

Humans are born with free will, but included in that free will is sin. We are natural born sinners. There is no way to completely rid oneself of sinning. We sin sometimes without even knowing it. I don't think God is asking us to become perfect beings or wants us to believe we are perfect. I believe that we show our “pure love” just with the choices that we make everyday. We are constantly challenged everyday to show whether we are going to act upon love. Without these challenges, how can we come to know love more? If we believe we are perfect that means we have nothing else to learn, and that in itself is wrong. There are so many things that we as humans still have yet to know and understand, so to think that you are “perfect” is almost putting yourself right up there with God. Only God knows all, and only God can comprehend what perfection actually is. We as humans haven't even ever comprehended perfection in itself, so how can we claim that we've reached that state? In Eastern Religion, with Buddhism, if one is seeking nirvana, one cannot claim they have been enlightened because that defeats the entire purpose of enlightenment. Striving to be better and to live in pure love is different than being perfect or claiming that you are. Whenever I meet someone who thinks they're perfect, I just ask them if they can walk on water. Problem solved!