The Loreto
Lauren Brooks
The other day Brooklyn and I ventured out on our own to examine this church and famous pilgrimage site. It was by far one of the weirdest and most interesting places I have been to so far in Prague. Looking at it afterwards it still feels like a very mysterious place. I don’t know where to begin. The Loreto is an Italian term and means the house where the annunciation of Jesus took place, it originated in Italy and when Christianity spread throughout Eastern Europe many replicas of these houses were built to help sway people to the Christian faith. All throughout Eastern Bohemia these churches sprang up and were very important in pilgrimages of the faith. It is connected with the Capuchin Order of Monks who still care for the chapel. It is widely by tourists for 2 main reasons, the immense collection of expensive jewels and the carillon bells.
Brooklyn and I had the chance to experience this amazing place and by far the most interesting exhibit were the immense and expensive jewels they had. The most expensive piece they had is called the Diamond Monstrance which features over 6,000 diamonds. This piece is only used on very very special occasions; the last time it was used was 1999 for a pilgrim celebration, over 300 years after it had been made. This room was literally blinding with the amount of jewels that these cups, altar pieces and crucifixes contained.
While I appreciate the splendor and the praise that these pieces of art were made for I also wonder where the line between worship and over-indulgence concerned in art is. The “gaudiness” of some of these pieces I really question? Couldn’t we hawk a bunch of these goblets, chalices, and altarpieces and feed like a third world country or half of Africa. I mean why do we need all this ornamentation, I don’t picture God as the kind of person who would want that gaudy chalice or altar piece, I think his focus would be on feeding the hungry, I mean isn’t that what our focus should be in being “like Christ”? Just something to think about the next time your church wants a new stain glassed window…
Friday, January 23, 2009
Wednesday, December 17, 2008
amy- The Sweet Calm
Monasteries always hold a degree of mystery and wonder to me. It takes me to a place of calm and peace within my heart. I feel free to let my mind wander and take me into the deepest recesses of my mind. Santa Croce in Florence is one of the places that stick out in my mind as being a place of calm. It seemed far removed from the typical “downtown” area of Florence, and made me think of the greatest artists ever known worshipping there. As I explored, a calm came over me. I never wanted to leave. Santa Croce was not crowded with tourists when we arrived; the clouds seemed to be moving in and out in accordance to my thoughts. I thought of history and those who might have taken comfort within Santa Croce’s walls. I thought of the combination of art and nature working so harmoniously together in the courtyards. I thought of the respect which the artists must have given when they painted for such a prominent church in Florence. Before we went, I remember myself feeling a bit flustered about having to change plans so quickly. As a group, we had planned on doing Santa Croce the second day, but we changed it literally as we took the bus into the city. I was nervous and uptight, ready to just “follow the schedule.” I am glad that we did Santa Croce that first evening. My attitude changed after being able to wander the courtyards on my own. I went into these quiet cave-like buildings that held displays which no one was visiting. I remember just wanting to stay there and think. I am glad for those quiet times in these amazing places we were able to visit over the semester.
amy- Recitation
In chapel, here at IBTS, they often have written prayers that are to be repeated. This is very foreign to me. I often wonder the efficacy of these prayers. When I say these “prayers,” most times it feels a bit hollow and awkward. I hardly recognize my own voice and I never feel like I am fully able to get the right prayer rhythm. I really do try and feel something from these prayers, but my feelings do not get the message. In all honesty, I do not mind saying these prayers, but I want to hear the thoughts of my brothers and sisters in Christ! I feel that genuine prayers give such great insight into each person’s personality. If someone stumbles in their prayer, I could care less. I like hearing the thoughts: this is what is important to me. We have so much to learn from one another’s spiritual walks. This is such a crucial part of true fellowship. Fellowship is created by the sharing of one another’s thoughts and struggles. Pseudo-fellowship is merely politeness and action without love. One of the greatest blessings in my Christian experience has been the sense of family in the church. To know you are cared about and loved as a sister or daughter is a great feeling. I am reminded of song lyrics that say “They will know we are Christians by our love.” Church communities tend to be known as more of a stiff, cold group of people. Though I do not think that the set prayers are harmful, I think that genuine prayers are helpful. Christian relationships should always encourage and build up rather than tear down. This does not happen in one day, but by slowly infusing a sense of genuineness and honesty within our communities.
amy- Reflection on Medieval Christianity's Art
I cannot say I receive any joy from medieval art. I suppose the answer to this would be the icons are not supposed to attract the viewer to the art, but there are times I wish it had more variety. I really understand the heaviness of the medieval time period. As the viewer examines the art, he is able to feel the oppressive nature of sameness. Purely artistically speaking, I understand the term “Dark Ages.” If I step back, however, I am able to understand the practical and useful function of these artistic pieces. A change occurred within me when I stepped back and examined this historical context. Looking at all the pietas or contemplative Marys no longer held boredom, but, rather, an interest in seeing how these might have affected those who were not able to read. Jesus’ death is portrayed in such a way that it is difficult for the viewer to look at the image for long. For those in the medieval time period, Jesus could be a comfort to them in their sufferings. And yet… it is very hard for modern day man to understand these portrayals. I find that I do not fully understand them. When I see baby Jesus portrayed as a “baby-man” I cannot really take it seriously. In our practically minded society, this picture strikes us as funny, but within the coherent whole of the medieval time period, this idea of Christ is perfectly understandable.
After studying both the Italian medieval art and the art shown at Saint Agnes’ convent, I am not surprised that the Renaissance began in Italy. I feel as though the icons and medieval art in Italy held a type of artistry that genuinely wished to convey the truths of Christ. I remember at the Accademia in Venice being stunned by the complex biblical concepts the artwork attempts to convey. It was about the story rather than the art. At Saint Agnes’s convent, I felt that the work is so simplified that it did not hold the depth of the art in Italy. The Italian art held hints of the incredible heights it would reach during the Italian Renaissance.
At the same time, I do not want to be too harsh on the artwork shown here in Prague. One is able to observe how the level of skill in the art increases as the viewer sees the time period change to the 16th century. It is as if someone had turned on the light and the artists start to become more innovative. I remember specifically one of the forerunners in the new wave is a Mary who the artist dresses in black. This depiction was so different, just from the colors, that it caught my eye immediately. It is strange how the smallest change in protocol can catch the eye of an observer. After that point in the gallery, I could see the slight changes in the artwork by giving Jesus different features or showing more genuine humanity in the Biblical stories. I think by learning about the medieval time period, I have become less harsh on medieval art. It will never be my favorite, but I have a better understanding of it.
After studying both the Italian medieval art and the art shown at Saint Agnes’ convent, I am not surprised that the Renaissance began in Italy. I feel as though the icons and medieval art in Italy held a type of artistry that genuinely wished to convey the truths of Christ. I remember at the Accademia in Venice being stunned by the complex biblical concepts the artwork attempts to convey. It was about the story rather than the art. At Saint Agnes’s convent, I felt that the work is so simplified that it did not hold the depth of the art in Italy. The Italian art held hints of the incredible heights it would reach during the Italian Renaissance.
At the same time, I do not want to be too harsh on the artwork shown here in Prague. One is able to observe how the level of skill in the art increases as the viewer sees the time period change to the 16th century. It is as if someone had turned on the light and the artists start to become more innovative. I remember specifically one of the forerunners in the new wave is a Mary who the artist dresses in black. This depiction was so different, just from the colors, that it caught my eye immediately. It is strange how the smallest change in protocol can catch the eye of an observer. After that point in the gallery, I could see the slight changes in the artwork by giving Jesus different features or showing more genuine humanity in the Biblical stories. I think by learning about the medieval time period, I have become less harsh on medieval art. It will never be my favorite, but I have a better understanding of it.
amy- The Crossing
I suppose it is a funny reality. Before this semester, I think I can safely say that Elise and I never ever thought of adopting any Catholic traditions. After this semester, I think we will have an accidental Catholic bond. I can also safely say Elise and I never would have examined our “accidental Catholicism” as academically as we did this year. The reader must understand: Elise and I have been in quite a few precarious situations. In Delphi, we were the triumphant mountain climbers, but most definitely not the triumphant dog tamers. Metaphorically and physically, the phrase “coming off the mountain,” definitely relates to us. We had a wonderful time reaching a shack on the top of a mountain in Delphi, but our bravado ceased as we attempted to find a way of getting around the loud, angry sounding barks of dogs. We would battle on, retreat, and then try and logically talk ourselves into facing the dogs. Elise and I would look at each other and go forward. We crossed the area where the fence was located. We heard the dogs barking. We looked at each other and both started crossing ourselves as we scrambled over rocks and trees trying to get out of that situation. This symbol of Christ somehow just naturally came into our minds. It was very strange, because both Elise and I come from a Protestant background. To make this story even more interesting is that we have done that not only once, but twice. When we somehow ended up in the Paris ghetto, again we looked at each other with wide frightened eyes and our hands moved from parallel to perpendicular. It is strange to find out what symbols one uses in extreme situations. Nevertheless, I think this experience can fall under the category of “experiential symbol use.”
amy- The Question of Perfection
Let me start with a disclaimer: I may be biased towards John Wesley. Yes, I have always admired his zeal. As I learn throughout my life though, zeal works as a double edged sword. Whenever one takes a strong stance for something, many times they are misunderstood and this zeal can hinder them from reaching more people. No doubt, however, this zeal also attracts some that would not normally be attracted in the first place. I see this in the case of John Wesley and discussing him in class. It is my personal opinion that John Wesley never believed that anyone could be perfect. I do not believe that he could have preached for as long as he did, and knowing the hearts of man as he did, without coming to this conclusion. I think his message was and is for believers who wish to follow Jesus’ way to the fullest extent of their ability. Yet, as I said before, this message seems as though it was strongly said, which sometimes leaves room for a one-sided understanding. If John Wesley is stressing the power of the Holy Spirit in a Christian’s life, it may seem as though he is stating the believer himself is achieving some form of perfection. If not understood in context, John Wesley sounds like another preacher trying to raise himself up. Paul in Romans speaks of the double nature of the Christian. To think that John Wesley did not understand this double nature and that he thought the Christian could be perfect would be to reject some of the most core beliefs of the Christian faith. Talking about John Wesley’s beliefs is interesting, but there must always be an understanding of the man in relation to the Bible. Assumptions must be made about John Wesley’s beliefs on the Bible as well. Do we think he saw Romans seven, ignored what Paul was saying, and decided that he indeed could be perfect?
amy- Counter Reformation
This summer I noticed that Dostoyevsky referenced the Jesuit order in his book The Brothers’ Karamazov quite a few times. Adding to my curiosity of Roman Catholicism or Catholicism in general, his reference seems to be very negative in parallel to the other monastic orders he references. I still probably do not know too much about the Jesuit order or the Counter Reformation, but I understand Dostoyevsky’s innuendos more from Garrett’s presentation. Like most things, the idea of the Jesuits is a beautiful ideal from the papacy at the time, but its true function turned into something quite different than the intention. The good intentions from the papacy were an attempt to overthrow the corruption of the priesthood and bring the Reformers back to the Catholic Church. The order of the Jesuits seems to mainly function as the right hand men of the pope. Now my impression of all this is one of extreme incredulity. Giving the pope the power of his own personal monastic order is dangerous. It seems that history has not been kind to this order either. Dostoyevsky makes the Jesuit name seem synonymous with trying to intellectually outwit the ideas of the Bible. I find it interesting that the order who is supposed to be closest to the pope is associated with rationalization. I think that Dostoyevsky’s book would be interesting to analyze according to what the book says about monastic life. His book is what really sparked my interest in the Counter Reformation and the contrast between the ideal and the evolution.
amy- A Blessing
So many strange things have happened throughout this semester. I came into the program without any idea of what the class schedule would be like, or what the people would be like. The first few weeks of a new environment are always a bit difficult, but the key seems to be one’s attitude to the set-up. I feel as though one of the stabilizations I was able to receive during this semester was the short chapels in the mornings and the communion chapel on Wednesdays. I am not much of a morning person, but these chapels really have kept me in check when it comes to late nights and routine. I need the motivation to get up in the morning and, more importantly, need to start my day thinking of God. For me, it felt like a continual Bible conference not unlike the ones I have attended since I was young. This additional sense of community really helped me to get to know the environment in which we are living. An important part of Christianity is the relationship between the human and God. We are able to come to God through Jesus and have the privilege to come to Him daily. During these chapels there are no real “profound” earth-quaking theological realizations, but there is another opportunity for God to speak through His people. As a Christian, it is the small truths of daily life that are shown in the chapels. Even the worship at the start of the day helps me focus on Christ more. I am always singing, so the singing in the chapel is a constructive way to outlet the desire.
amy- The Shock of Luther
I understand that Luther was amazing. I really do. I admire him for really following his beliefs, and yet I find myself saddened for his legacy. No one finds themselves more surprised at this fact than myself. Now let me clarify. It does not change my initial opinions on the work of Luther, it just shows one the fallibility of man. I feel as though it is obvious that I am referring to the anti-Semitism of Luther. I have never done any research on my own about Luther, so I was surprised to hear that he was as vehemently against the Jews as he was for the reforming of the Catholic Church. It makes me think of a quote that has stuck with me: “There but for the grace of God go I.” In this case, it makes me think of how Christians just hope and trust the grace of God covers their sins. Luther is just another example of how the most spiritually gigantic people can fall. Luther’s sin of hatred to another race has horrifying repercussions, but within it all is found the grace of God. The same thing can be seen in the case of David from the Bible. His sin with Bathsheba had terrible consequences for his family, but in the end he was restored back to God. For me, this is how I have to examine Luther’s life and pray that I can learn from his mistake of forgetting the love of God that extends to friends and enemies alike.
amy- The Legacy of Jan Hus
Well, I would suppose it is obvious why Jan Hus is so fascinating now more than ever. It is strange how prevalent his name is in Prague, even now. I think for us, as Americans, this should give us insight as to the nature of the religious wars that took place in Prague and the Czech Republic. In general, I think it is hard for us to completely understand the violence and insanity of the Protestant Reformation and the Thirty Years’ War. Can I really even understand an inkling of Hus’s conviction? Do have even an inkling of the kind of strength to be burned by fire? I always think of the martyrs of Christ as having some sort of amazing personality trait that elevated them above the rest, but I think it is not so. I think their faith in Jesus and belief in the truth of the Bible was what sustained them through their persecution. I often try and find a “unique” aspect of Hus’s persecution, and then I try to take a step back. His job was taken away, he was excommunicated, arrested and finally brutally killed. When one thinks about the intensity of all those actions, there does not need to be some “defining feature” amidst all those things. Those things should be more than enough to remember. Nevertheless, my favorite part of the Hus presentation was most definitely finding out that Hus’s last words apparently referred to Martin Luther. This, ironically enough, is what I remember most about Hus—his “defining feature.” Even now, I cannot quite wrap my mind around such prophetic words.
amy- The Forerunner: John Wycliffe
I really loved learning about the bold nature of John Wycliffe. It is funny, because I feel as though not many would remember him as a large part of the Protestant Reformation. Reading more about him fascinated me. Especially within the church, it makes me happy to see that there were some people who could not bear to see the church defame the name of Christ. John Wycliffe did this. I think I also really like the role that he took in the Reformation. It was as if his writings were sitting underground like a landmine, just waiting for the right person to discover the truth they contained. Where did Jan Hus and Martin Luther get a lot of their outlines and ideas? They received it directly from the Bull that Wycliffe sent directly to the Pope. Another humorous aspect to Wycliffe’s life is the fact that the church exhumed his bones so that they could burn another heretic. As a Christian, seeing how zealously Wycliffe wanted to get the Bible into the hands of the people inspires me to treasure my own Bible more. I was really fascinated with the attitude of Wycliffe. He was so concerned with what the Bible truly meant and was not working any angle other than truth. I wish to have that sort of character: the sort of character that is concerned with the truth, but the truth with love. Wycliffe wanted each individual to read what the Bible really said and work out his or her own faith. He no longer wanted people to blindly follow the manipulated “Biblical teachings” that the church leaders instated. When I read what he had to say about the indulgences and the greed of the church, I could see his righteous anger burning for the citizens who were being swindled by those who were supposedly doing “God’s work.” Once again, it is merely inspiring.
Amanda: Jesus camp
Our conversation about the perfection doctrine as well as our later discussion on various movements in the Pentecostal church made me rehash my experience of watching the controversial film, Jesus Camp. The film documents a summer camp of charismatic evangelicals led by Pastor Becky Fischer in North Dakota. Here, the children are taught to speak in tongues, pray to a cardboard cut out of George Bush, and put on plays dressed in camouflage to represent their identity as “Christian soldiers.”
To be honest, this film terrified me and even moved me to tears at some points. It wasn’t just that I didn’t understand the way they chose to worship, or how they chose to raise their kids, it was that I felt so much hatred and judgment from Fischer, as well as the children, as young as 6 years old. Fischer even goes so far as to compare the camp she has created to Islamic schools which prepare children for jihad. She then goes on to say, “I want to see them radically laying down their lives for the gospel as they are in Pakistan, in Israel, in Palestine and all those different places.” The thought of bringing children up to have the mindset of war and being in ‘the army of God’ seems so obviously far off from what Jesus’ life clearly exemplified and completely blows my mind.
I have had little to no interaction with people who actually believe these things, yet I find it absolutely fascinating that Christianity can be interpreted in such drastically different ways. On the topics of indoctrinating as well as a desire to fuse church and state, Fischer outright admits in the film that this is their goal. The Camp itself is designed to provoke these kids to want to pursue roles in politics later in life in order to “take back America for Christ.”
Ted haggard and new life church is also featured in the film, and interestingly, Haggard comments on homosexuality. The film clip features him preaching in front of his congregation and saying “we don’t have to debate about homosexuality, the answer is clearly written in the bible” and then goes on to jokingly say to one of the cameras who are filming him, “I think I know what you did last night, if you pay me a million dollars I won’t tell your wife.” Well, if that isn’t the most ironic thing I’ve ever heard….
I would highly recommend this film for anyone interested, but I would warn that it might leave you a bit broken and wondering how the life and teaching of Jesus have been and continue to be so misused.
Here is the trailer:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RNfL6IVWCE
To be honest, this film terrified me and even moved me to tears at some points. It wasn’t just that I didn’t understand the way they chose to worship, or how they chose to raise their kids, it was that I felt so much hatred and judgment from Fischer, as well as the children, as young as 6 years old. Fischer even goes so far as to compare the camp she has created to Islamic schools which prepare children for jihad. She then goes on to say, “I want to see them radically laying down their lives for the gospel as they are in Pakistan, in Israel, in Palestine and all those different places.” The thought of bringing children up to have the mindset of war and being in ‘the army of God’ seems so obviously far off from what Jesus’ life clearly exemplified and completely blows my mind.
I have had little to no interaction with people who actually believe these things, yet I find it absolutely fascinating that Christianity can be interpreted in such drastically different ways. On the topics of indoctrinating as well as a desire to fuse church and state, Fischer outright admits in the film that this is their goal. The Camp itself is designed to provoke these kids to want to pursue roles in politics later in life in order to “take back America for Christ.”
Ted haggard and new life church is also featured in the film, and interestingly, Haggard comments on homosexuality. The film clip features him preaching in front of his congregation and saying “we don’t have to debate about homosexuality, the answer is clearly written in the bible” and then goes on to jokingly say to one of the cameras who are filming him, “I think I know what you did last night, if you pay me a million dollars I won’t tell your wife.” Well, if that isn’t the most ironic thing I’ve ever heard….
I would highly recommend this film for anyone interested, but I would warn that it might leave you a bit broken and wondering how the life and teaching of Jesus have been and continue to be so misused.
Here is the trailer:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6RNfL6IVWCE
Tuesday, December 16, 2008
Amanda- The wealth of God
Throughout the semester we have talked a lot about the shift in the role of the Christian church in society throughout history. One important aspect that kept coming up a lot with my processing of all the sights we’ve seen and the conversations we’ve shared is the wealth of the church as well as how the church is supposed to gain as well as use the money they have. We have come across some of the most extravagant, incredibly costly cathedrals and basilicas on our trip and have studied much corruption and abuse of power in the church. The subjects of indulgences, tithing, and financial prosperity of the church have provoked more study of what the direct biblical response is to these topics.
Two specific segments of the bible immediately come to my mind when dealing with these issues. The first has been brought up many times in class, which is the story of Jesus turning over the tables of those who were selling things in front of and inside the temple. The second is one of my favorite verses from the bible, and describes Jesus’ reaction to the question of if he thought it was right to pay taxes. Jesus responds, “Give to Caesar that which belongs to Caesar, and to God that which belongs to God” (Mark 12:13-17).
In both biblical examples it seems very clear what Jesus’ stance is in regards to money and the relationship the church is to have with it. Instead of falling trap to the Pharisees and saying that it wasn’t right to pay taxes so they could arrest him, he disregarded money as a concern of God, and questioned the motives of the men for even asking in the first place.
Two specific segments of the bible immediately come to my mind when dealing with these issues. The first has been brought up many times in class, which is the story of Jesus turning over the tables of those who were selling things in front of and inside the temple. The second is one of my favorite verses from the bible, and describes Jesus’ reaction to the question of if he thought it was right to pay taxes. Jesus responds, “Give to Caesar that which belongs to Caesar, and to God that which belongs to God” (Mark 12:13-17).
In both biblical examples it seems very clear what Jesus’ stance is in regards to money and the relationship the church is to have with it. Instead of falling trap to the Pharisees and saying that it wasn’t right to pay taxes so they could arrest him, he disregarded money as a concern of God, and questioned the motives of the men for even asking in the first place.
Amanda: Christianity in context
There is an incredible tension that occurs between making faith relevant to a culture, and stepping outside the fundamental beliefs of that religion. Separating doctrine from the core morals and beliefs which the rest of a religion is founded on is practically impossible yet doctrine can’t be the sole unifying factor between people of the same faith. The story of Bruce Olsen that we talked about in class is a perfect example of how the gospel of Christianity was successfully explained to people who had no knowledge of a Jewish Jesus, yet some might argue that this takes away from the power of the story.
It is true that the Jewish law does play a pivotal point in explaining the emergence of Christianity, but to me it is far more important to first establish a connecting factor which all people can understand before more elaborate concepts of the Christian faith can be presented. I would argue then that regardless of time period, cultural factors, religion or race, the accounts of the life and actions of Jesus should be the main focus, rather than the details of the story. If the purpose of sharing the gospel is in fact to help those who are confused and misguided by all the contradictions in the world and to turn them towards faith, this seems like it should be an obvious solution to the problem.
It is true that the Jewish law does play a pivotal point in explaining the emergence of Christianity, but to me it is far more important to first establish a connecting factor which all people can understand before more elaborate concepts of the Christian faith can be presented. I would argue then that regardless of time period, cultural factors, religion or race, the accounts of the life and actions of Jesus should be the main focus, rather than the details of the story. If the purpose of sharing the gospel is in fact to help those who are confused and misguided by all the contradictions in the world and to turn them towards faith, this seems like it should be an obvious solution to the problem.
Amanda- The necessity of language as a symbol
The conversation we had in class the other day about the use of language in religion completely culminated my current struggles in my own spiritual journey. I’ve always accepted the fact that language as well as all types of art are a way to respond to experiences as well as a means of communicating your own experiences to others, but until recently I haven’t been able to verbalize my frustration with their limitations.
It is an undeniable part of humans that we all search for meaning and that we attempt to live lives that correspond with the truth we have come to understand in the world, but this idea of personal truth or reality sparks much controversy. On one hand, you can’t let others just tell you what to believe, you have to understand it for yourself, but on the other hand there must be some sort of unity and community in order for progress to occur. In my opinion, this is one of the biggest struggles that all religions face in appealing to non-believers and believers alike.
The idea of language merely being a metaphor for truth made a lot of sense for me, and really clicked with my understanding of religion. The symbol of religion will never be able to fully encompass the holy, omnipotent, all knowing God which it claims to represent, yet it is necessary in order to mediate the struggle of the human pursuit of truth. We must never claim that any of us know absolute truth in our own language or anything else which is beyond the moment of experience, yet we must use language to communicate with one another to share and grow in faith.
It is an undeniable part of humans that we all search for meaning and that we attempt to live lives that correspond with the truth we have come to understand in the world, but this idea of personal truth or reality sparks much controversy. On one hand, you can’t let others just tell you what to believe, you have to understand it for yourself, but on the other hand there must be some sort of unity and community in order for progress to occur. In my opinion, this is one of the biggest struggles that all religions face in appealing to non-believers and believers alike.
The idea of language merely being a metaphor for truth made a lot of sense for me, and really clicked with my understanding of religion. The symbol of religion will never be able to fully encompass the holy, omnipotent, all knowing God which it claims to represent, yet it is necessary in order to mediate the struggle of the human pursuit of truth. We must never claim that any of us know absolute truth in our own language or anything else which is beyond the moment of experience, yet we must use language to communicate with one another to share and grow in faith.
Sunday, December 14, 2008
Final - AHB
This class has been an interesting survey of a number of different issues related to Christianity. It was an incredible experience to expand my learning with trips to some of the most important sites for the early church. Seeing these places gave the stories an added depth. I didn't walk away with a life-changing encounter with God but I did learn to evaluate religion with a more nuanced perspective. There are many of us whose past causes us to flee religion like the plague; however, I hope to never give up the understanding that the search for god is of utmost importance for human life. I have an insatiable desire to understand the beginning of truth and life, and whether or not I come to believe in one or many divinities that is a decision that will profoundly impact the rest of my life.
What has been most interesting this semester is our discussions on myth. Most Christians would shy away from calling their religious beliefs myths, and this has always been one of my strong contentions with Christianity. We know that even the Bible has experienced a host of changes and revisions since it was first written down. And the earliest accounts would have existed for a long time in a strictly oral tradition. There are reams of examples of contradictory claims within the Bible, and in order to resolve these issues one must make some pretty difficult logical jumps ("He who has eyes" - I guess).
Modern Christianity has done a disservice to its tradition. Churches today seem completely ineffectual, and I become increasingly disgusted by their attempts to turn their message into, "Be a Rich, Happy, and Successful Believer" (That's for Mr.'s Olsteen and Warren). God is used like a music box to get people to dance to someone's tune. These "ministers" have no idea how to connect and impact society. When Jesus commands to "be in the world, but not of it" I'm pretty sure that his meaning was drastically different than what we see today.
I don't think I can say that my religious views concretely changed a great deal, but I no longer see myth as united with ignorance. We learn a great deal about ourselves by investigating the myths that give us meaning, and I think that if nothing else, religion is useful in that respect.
What has been most interesting this semester is our discussions on myth. Most Christians would shy away from calling their religious beliefs myths, and this has always been one of my strong contentions with Christianity. We know that even the Bible has experienced a host of changes and revisions since it was first written down. And the earliest accounts would have existed for a long time in a strictly oral tradition. There are reams of examples of contradictory claims within the Bible, and in order to resolve these issues one must make some pretty difficult logical jumps ("He who has eyes" - I guess).
Modern Christianity has done a disservice to its tradition. Churches today seem completely ineffectual, and I become increasingly disgusted by their attempts to turn their message into, "Be a Rich, Happy, and Successful Believer" (That's for Mr.'s Olsteen and Warren). God is used like a music box to get people to dance to someone's tune. These "ministers" have no idea how to connect and impact society. When Jesus commands to "be in the world, but not of it" I'm pretty sure that his meaning was drastically different than what we see today.
I don't think I can say that my religious views concretely changed a great deal, but I no longer see myth as united with ignorance. We learn a great deal about ourselves by investigating the myths that give us meaning, and I think that if nothing else, religion is useful in that respect.
Martin Buber...I think
Garrett Lambur
Before this semester I had never been exposed Martin Buber’s I and Thou and I found it to be quite an interesting subject. In all honesty at first I struggled to wrap my mind around the idea of an I and it relationship and a I and you relationship, there was something very foreign in the idea for me. What still somewhat boggles my mind is the idea of an I and you relationship as the relationship between I and the “wholly other” but that it cannot be named for that makes the relationship an I, it, and destroys the relationship. To justify my understanding of this I have to put the idea of I and it and I and you into context for myself. I understand these may not be exactly what Buber was saying but it is how I interpreted it. An I and it relationship is one that relates more to a possessive nature of an inanimate object. There is no two-way path were emotions or feelings are shared between the two. The relationship does not allow for any sort of positive growth as a human being, the relationship is seen as a means to an end. In contrast, the I and you relationship is one that does not exist based upon material possessions. It can allow for personal growth as a human being as you share a relationship. There is no ability to possess the you, the you is, it exists beyond a means to an end, there is more than just trade of something in return for something wanted. Only in these contexts does the idea that as soon as you attempt to name a relationship with God does it become an I and it relationship. For as soon as you name it an it relationship you are attempting to quantify the relationship, which is not possible in an I and you relationship. The I and you relationship simply exists and allows for growth but cannot be labeled, it just has to be accepted.
Buber stated that people only usually see people as It’s and not You’s which I believe is mostly true. In my life I cannot think of many relationships that I have that do not fall outside of the It realm. I always seem to attempt in my head to quantify my friendship with people, to question it, how strong is it, what would they do for me and what would I do for them? By doing so I am immediately attempting to quantify it. I would like to think that my relationship with my parents is an I and You relationship but there are times where I find myself quantifying it. I have to say that I see their view of the relationship to me is I and you, I am their son, nothing else matters, they would love me no matter what happens in my life. Of course I cannot truly know if it is such a relationship but I hope it is. The more I attempt to think about this subject the more confused I make myself for just by thinking about I and you it seems I would be degrading such a relationship thus making all relationships in my life I and it, which I view as a sad thing. I can say that after pondering this, philosophy is not my strong point for this is not the first thing I have struggled with attempting to understand.
Before this semester I had never been exposed Martin Buber’s I and Thou and I found it to be quite an interesting subject. In all honesty at first I struggled to wrap my mind around the idea of an I and it relationship and a I and you relationship, there was something very foreign in the idea for me. What still somewhat boggles my mind is the idea of an I and you relationship as the relationship between I and the “wholly other” but that it cannot be named for that makes the relationship an I, it, and destroys the relationship. To justify my understanding of this I have to put the idea of I and it and I and you into context for myself. I understand these may not be exactly what Buber was saying but it is how I interpreted it. An I and it relationship is one that relates more to a possessive nature of an inanimate object. There is no two-way path were emotions or feelings are shared between the two. The relationship does not allow for any sort of positive growth as a human being, the relationship is seen as a means to an end. In contrast, the I and you relationship is one that does not exist based upon material possessions. It can allow for personal growth as a human being as you share a relationship. There is no ability to possess the you, the you is, it exists beyond a means to an end, there is more than just trade of something in return for something wanted. Only in these contexts does the idea that as soon as you attempt to name a relationship with God does it become an I and it relationship. For as soon as you name it an it relationship you are attempting to quantify the relationship, which is not possible in an I and you relationship. The I and you relationship simply exists and allows for growth but cannot be labeled, it just has to be accepted.
Buber stated that people only usually see people as It’s and not You’s which I believe is mostly true. In my life I cannot think of many relationships that I have that do not fall outside of the It realm. I always seem to attempt in my head to quantify my friendship with people, to question it, how strong is it, what would they do for me and what would I do for them? By doing so I am immediately attempting to quantify it. I would like to think that my relationship with my parents is an I and You relationship but there are times where I find myself quantifying it. I have to say that I see their view of the relationship to me is I and you, I am their son, nothing else matters, they would love me no matter what happens in my life. Of course I cannot truly know if it is such a relationship but I hope it is. The more I attempt to think about this subject the more confused I make myself for just by thinking about I and you it seems I would be degrading such a relationship thus making all relationships in my life I and it, which I view as a sad thing. I can say that after pondering this, philosophy is not my strong point for this is not the first thing I have struggled with attempting to understand.
Zeitgeist - AHB
After my last blog I figured it would be appropriate to review the film Zeitgeist and consider some of its ideas and messages. Unfortunately, as we all know, the internet connection here is pretty atrocious, so this is in no way meant to be a review of the entire film (I'm streaming it online). The film begins by a quote that effectively sums up the main contention in the film: "They must find it difficult . . . Those who have taken authority as the truth, rather than truth as the authority." What the filmmakers go on to do is investigate a lot of different claims of truth made by politicians and religious figures. On the one hand this movie feels like an absurd conspiracy-theory, but I don't think that it so be so readily dismissed. For one thing this short film has become huge in certain circles, and is interesting for that reason if nothing else.
Part I of the film investigates the central claims of Christianity. The primary message is that very few of Christianity's central claims are original. Most were taken from Pagan and Egyptian religious beliefs and practices. Principally, Pagan religions focused on the sun and the twelve constellations of the Zodiac. The Sun was seen as the divine messenger between God and earth/mankind. The Egyptian's built on to this belief by turning the generic Sun-God into Horus (3000 BC). Horus was also the God of light, and he was locked in a titanic struggle against the "prince of darkness" (so to speak) Set. Their battle took place daily which explained the rising and setting of the sun. There are also many other similarities that Horus shares with Christ: born of a virgin on Dec. 25th (obviously Christ's birth in this sense is traditional rather than actual), worshiped as a babe by 3 kings underneath a peculiar star, became a teacher at 12, began public ministry at 30, and gathered 12 disciples who helped him perform miracles and walk on water. Horus was betrayed, crucified, dead for three days, and then resurrected.
Following this discussion of Horus the film goes on to demonstrate that many other religious deities (Krishna, Attis, Dionysus, Mithra) had these same characteristics, so much so that it is nearly impossible to know who came first. The point is that these "solar messiahs" have existed throughout human history, and Christ is only the most recent among many. The whole system is entirely astrological, but I won't go into the whole explanation here.
If we assume that myths are an extremely essential part of human life, we must ask ourselves another question: which myth do we believe? Are all religions just a reinterpretation of this main theme? And if so, why ascribe to Christianity before all others?
There will always be rounds and rounds of arguments over claims like this - and I am in no way saying that I buy in to the contention made in this film. Here, for example, is a religious studies professor making counter-claims - http://singinginthereign.blogspot.com/2007/07/zeitgeist-movie-is-christianity.html - The point I want to make is that it is so difficult to determine truth in these kinds of circumstances. Some might say that this creates the need for myth, but what is that myth supposed to make us feel? Should we believe any religious claims simply on the basis that they give our lives a false sense of worth? Most arguments like this make me want to forget the whole damn thing.
Part I of the film investigates the central claims of Christianity. The primary message is that very few of Christianity's central claims are original. Most were taken from Pagan and Egyptian religious beliefs and practices. Principally, Pagan religions focused on the sun and the twelve constellations of the Zodiac. The Sun was seen as the divine messenger between God and earth/mankind. The Egyptian's built on to this belief by turning the generic Sun-God into Horus (3000 BC). Horus was also the God of light, and he was locked in a titanic struggle against the "prince of darkness" (so to speak) Set. Their battle took place daily which explained the rising and setting of the sun. There are also many other similarities that Horus shares with Christ: born of a virgin on Dec. 25th (obviously Christ's birth in this sense is traditional rather than actual), worshiped as a babe by 3 kings underneath a peculiar star, became a teacher at 12, began public ministry at 30, and gathered 12 disciples who helped him perform miracles and walk on water. Horus was betrayed, crucified, dead for three days, and then resurrected.
Following this discussion of Horus the film goes on to demonstrate that many other religious deities (Krishna, Attis, Dionysus, Mithra) had these same characteristics, so much so that it is nearly impossible to know who came first. The point is that these "solar messiahs" have existed throughout human history, and Christ is only the most recent among many. The whole system is entirely astrological, but I won't go into the whole explanation here.
If we assume that myths are an extremely essential part of human life, we must ask ourselves another question: which myth do we believe? Are all religions just a reinterpretation of this main theme? And if so, why ascribe to Christianity before all others?
There will always be rounds and rounds of arguments over claims like this - and I am in no way saying that I buy in to the contention made in this film. Here, for example, is a religious studies professor making counter-claims - http://singinginthereign.blogspot.com/2007/07/zeitgeist-movie-is-christianity.html - The point I want to make is that it is so difficult to determine truth in these kinds of circumstances. Some might say that this creates the need for myth, but what is that myth supposed to make us feel? Should we believe any religious claims simply on the basis that they give our lives a false sense of worth? Most arguments like this make me want to forget the whole damn thing.
Atheism - AHB
About a year or so ago I watched a trailer for the film "Zeitgeist", which is a deeply anti-institutional film shot in a faux-documentary style. My interest with this film was not so much geared toward the political overtones, but rather with the religious message. Around this same time I became interested with the religion-themed writings of Sam Harris, Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, and Betrand Russell. I do not consider myself an atheist (and even many atheist author do not consider themselves to be such because of logical reasons), but I've long since given up on pursuing spirituality in a structured sense. Part of the reason for this is because I spent an inordinate amount of my childhood trying to live out doctrines that no longer mean anything to me. My feeling is that if god's representative people on earth are not worth following, he/she probably isn't either. Anyway, it is interesting how trendy atheism is starting to be in certain circles. I think the fact that so few people regard themselves as pure atheists shows that our society is still skeptical at best (or worst depending on your perspective). Ever since people started misquoting Karl Marx's "religion is the opium of the masses" there has been a kind of seductiveness to the atheist position. Sometimes people just want to be considered a minority. It is still clear that Christianity is the dominant belief in American society - I think a homosexual muslim would have a better chance of ascending to the presidency than an atheist, but there is some pretty strong undercurrents moving through society. And I think the passing of the baby boomer generation will only continue that trend.
I'm not really sure where I'm going with this blog. I just think that there are a lot of interesting perspectives going around today, and some of them deserve a look.
This is a recent quote from the L.A. Times that I found interesting: "In the end, even these specifics don’t intrigue me as much as this fact: Zero-sum arguments about faith and faithlessness just go round and round, generating heat and no light. It’s better to return to real knowledge and fundamental questions. Rather than arguing over the existence of God, rather than playing believer-nonbeliever gotcha, we learn a whole lot more if we just keep asking ourselves—in as many new ways as possible—why it is that so many of us feel compelled to pray."
Here's another quote by Sam Harris that really represents the growing thinking of many:
"If there are objective truths about human well-being—if kindness, for instance, is generally more conducive to happiness than cruelty is—then there seems little doubt that science will one day be able to make strong and precise claims about which of our behaviors and uses of attention are morally good, which are neutral, and which are bad. At time when only 28 percent of Americans will admit the truth of evolution, while 58 percent imagine that a belief in God is necessary for morality, it is truism to say that our culture is not prepared to think critically about the changes to come."
I'm not really sure where I'm going with this blog. I just think that there are a lot of interesting perspectives going around today, and some of them deserve a look.
This is a recent quote from the L.A. Times that I found interesting: "In the end, even these specifics don’t intrigue me as much as this fact: Zero-sum arguments about faith and faithlessness just go round and round, generating heat and no light. It’s better to return to real knowledge and fundamental questions. Rather than arguing over the existence of God, rather than playing believer-nonbeliever gotcha, we learn a whole lot more if we just keep asking ourselves—in as many new ways as possible—why it is that so many of us feel compelled to pray."
Here's another quote by Sam Harris that really represents the growing thinking of many:
"If there are objective truths about human well-being—if kindness, for instance, is generally more conducive to happiness than cruelty is—then there seems little doubt that science will one day be able to make strong and precise claims about which of our behaviors and uses of attention are morally good, which are neutral, and which are bad. At time when only 28 percent of Americans will admit the truth of evolution, while 58 percent imagine that a belief in God is necessary for morality, it is truism to say that our culture is not prepared to think critically about the changes to come."
Where are the Christians?
Where are the Christians?
Lauren Brooks
There have been many things that have surprised me since I have been here and traveling around Europe; for instance, the plethora of mullets, the numerous amounts of Americans everywhere, and the lack of peanut butter. But by far the thing that has surprised me the most is the lack of religious people in Europe. We have all traveled all over and experienced many different countries and had the privilege of meeting new people. Of course when meeting these people the usually pleasantries ensue and almost immediately the question of “what are you studying here?” is asked. At first I felt someone what ok in explaining that we were studying Religion in film and the arts mostly specifically from a European point of view, but after a couple of interesting responses I have become a little afraid of telling people what I study.
“Do we even have churches here in Prague?” “Religion, so are you like a priest or something, can girls do that?” Now granted a lot of these responses have come from conversations in a bar or club over a few beers and yelling across a smoky room, but at the same time the large amount of statistics I have observed continue to reinforce this conclusion. Despite the fact that we attend class and live at a seminary school I have barely noticed any religious people in this city. However, what does being “religious” really mean and better yet how do you see it? I just figured that being in such a historically religious region of the world would mean lots of religious people. I am so jealous that these people get to worship in these beautiful places with so much history and to me it seems like they don’t even notice half the time. Meeting all kinds of different people has showed me some huge differences in Americans compared to Europeans. I just know now that all the time I have spent in these sacred places I won’t take for granted.
Lauren Brooks
There have been many things that have surprised me since I have been here and traveling around Europe; for instance, the plethora of mullets, the numerous amounts of Americans everywhere, and the lack of peanut butter. But by far the thing that has surprised me the most is the lack of religious people in Europe. We have all traveled all over and experienced many different countries and had the privilege of meeting new people. Of course when meeting these people the usually pleasantries ensue and almost immediately the question of “what are you studying here?” is asked. At first I felt someone what ok in explaining that we were studying Religion in film and the arts mostly specifically from a European point of view, but after a couple of interesting responses I have become a little afraid of telling people what I study.
“Do we even have churches here in Prague?” “Religion, so are you like a priest or something, can girls do that?” Now granted a lot of these responses have come from conversations in a bar or club over a few beers and yelling across a smoky room, but at the same time the large amount of statistics I have observed continue to reinforce this conclusion. Despite the fact that we attend class and live at a seminary school I have barely noticed any religious people in this city. However, what does being “religious” really mean and better yet how do you see it? I just figured that being in such a historically religious region of the world would mean lots of religious people. I am so jealous that these people get to worship in these beautiful places with so much history and to me it seems like they don’t even notice half the time. Meeting all kinds of different people has showed me some huge differences in Americans compared to Europeans. I just know now that all the time I have spent in these sacred places I won’t take for granted.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)